-A +A

Pawn for the Wrong President

By Donald Wilson Bush, 6 June 2010

"Lee Hamilton violates his institution's charter by aiding the White House in appeasing Turkish leaders"

On the surface, the Woodrow Wilson International Center (WWC) for Scholar’s intent to honor Turkish Foreign Minister, Ahmet Davutoglu, on June 17 th with this year’s WWC Public Service Award seems innocent enough. But, in my opinion, it is not- and those closest to the situation would certainly agree.
Not least among those in the know are the president and executive director of the American Hellenic Institute who penned an open letter to WWC executive director Lee H. Hamilton on May 21, 2010 questioning the wisdom (but not the motive) of the WWC’s choice for receiving this year’s award. I am today, however, questioning the motive as well.

As a direct descendant of Woodrow Wilson’s great-grandfather, and a bearer of the family name (and the President’s proud heritage), I have been careful over 47 years to quietly honor the sacred space between family privilege and personal politics by purposefully recusing myself of every good and self-serving opportunity that might dishonor or misrepresent President Wilson’s cherished legacy. I have also watched closely that the numerous institutions bearing his name do the same.

From the family’s perspective this is important because institutions can, and often do (as a result of bureaucratic inertia and personal compromise) lose connection with the purpose and ideals that once animated the individual for whom an institution is named.

In the case of knowing what the WWC should stand for, one can find clues to what animated Woodrow Wilson the man by considering the catalogue of authorized biographies and Dr. Arthur Link’s impressive pile of presidential papers carefully preserved by the Library of Congress and published by Princeton University Press.

One can also integrate with this official archive of public memorabilia, family stories, letters, journal entries, newsprint pieces, photographs, personal affects and third party correspondence to find the spark of personal inspiration that animated the president’s dreams. This I have done with Wilson’s legacy for nearly three decades and I will continue to do it for the rest of my life.

From a personal perspective such as this, I can easily attest to the fact that Woodrow Wilson was every bit a poet as he was a politician. Consequently he was as much motivated by his own Scots-Irish wellspring of authenticity and substance as he was by his natural instinct for calculation and ambition. This is important to note because it has direct bearing on how one should interpret Wilson’s attitude toward the Eurasian minor states that had been suppressed, unjustly attacked and systematically slaughtered by the Ottoman Turks.

In short, Woodrow Wilson was motivated at his core by a strong sense of poetic justice and hero projection—in his case born of a strong predisposition for Christian duty and compassion—that inspired young men of his day to advocate for the little guy and the underdog.

Although he didn’t do this perfectly (his blind eye to the plight of African Americans is well noted), he did advocate, and advocated STRONGLY, for the successful emancipation of Eurasian minor states in the aftermath of WWI. This he did from his core, from his soul, from his heart. And this unique combination of a scholar’s poetic passion for justice and Truth—wedded with a political statesman’s genius for taking decisive, informed action in the time of national crisis—is that for which Woodrow Wilson the man is best remembered.

Without question, this fair reflection of Woodrow Wilson’s highest ideals in favor of the underdog, as described above, is also part of that Wilsonian legacy for which the WWC was specifically chartered to preserve through their selection of programs, projects, scholars (and award recipients).

However, with the questionable choice of Ahmet Davutoglu to receive the WWC’s highest award this year, I must now blow the whistle and redraw a blurred line that protects President Wilson’s historic legacy from the unscrupulous ambitions of those presently representing WWC’s bureaucratic leadership.

May I remind us all of the WWC’s charter as reflected in the words of the WWC mission statement? I quote—the mission of the WWC is “to commemorate the ideals and concerns of Woodrow Wilson by: providing a link between the world of ideas and the world of policy; and fostering research, study, discussion, and collaboration among a full spectrum of individuals concerned with policy and scholarship in national and world affairs.”

With all the recent blow back from their choice to honor Turkish Foreign Minister, Ahmet Davutoglu—a figure despised by many Eurasian people groups and thousands of activists worldwide punished as a result of his government’s unjust domestic and foreign policies—the present WWC leadership should at least consult President Wilson’s collected papers to see the error in their judgment. For if they do, they will find clear evidence of what was in the mind of our 28th president regarding his desire for the people of Eurasia and how, if he were alive today, he might interpret the idea of promoting “collaboration among a full spectrum of individuals concerned” relative to today’s US-Turkish foreign policy.

As contained in The Arbitral Award On Turkish-Armenian Boundary, dated November 22, 1920, we have a record of Wilson’s own words: “I have approached this difficult task with eagerness to serve the best interests of the Armenian people as well as the remaining inhabitants, of whatever race or religious belief they may be, in this stricken country, attempting to exercise also the strictest possible justice toward the populations, whether Turkish, Kurdish, Greek or Armenian, living in the adjacent areas.”

With this clear record of President Wilson’s intent, what could possibly cause Lee Hamilton and his staff to cow-tow to White House pressure in this instance of Turkish diplomatic appeasement even at the cost of dishonoring Woodrow Wilson’s personal wishes and thereby violating the WCC’s very own mission and purpose?

Is it simply a matter of Mr. Hamilton playing his part in a “good-old-boy” insider deal between President Obama’s State Department and the WWC? (That seems plausible given the fact that as the former chairman of the House Foreign Affairs Committee, Hamilton promoted the careers of many staffers now writing Barack Obama’s foreign policy– namely: Obama foreign policy advisor and deputy national security advisor Denis McDonough, Director for the Middle East Dan Shapiro, Obama campaign foreign policy speechwriter turned Deputy National Security Advisor for Strategic Communications Ben Rhodes, among others.) [For more details on that see story by foreign policy reporter Laura Rozen posted May 3, 2010 on Politico.com]

Or could it possibly be a matter of Mr. Hamilton’s unwavering American patriotism and an honest desire to ensure long-term US access to Turkish military airbases? In the past Turkish leaders have made veiled threats to alter the US-Turkey relationship should the US Congress officially recognize the historic truth of Turkey’s role in the Armenian Genocide. Hmmm.

Or perhaps it’s simply Mr. Hamilton’s heartfelt commitment to free market economics. With billions of dollars in potential profits from natural gas pipelines at stake for Wall Street—not to mention his friend Dick Gephardt’s multi-national Turkish lobby partners at the DC/Atlanta-based Gephardt Group—how much money will be lost should the US State Department fail to secure Turkey’s compliance in the trillion dollar energy deal? (Google: “Nabucco” “South Stream” “pipeline” ”Russia” to get the full picture.)

In the final analysis, it is most certainly a complex combination of all these factors that have influenced Mr. Hamilton’s decision to do the President’s bidding in this diplomatic business with Turkey. Sadly, even on a good day in Washington, DC, such blatant accounts of bureaucratic self-service like Mr. Hamilton’s come at a price to the institutions they serve and the historical legacies they are chartered to protect.

In this case—even if it is simply a matter of helping out his good buddy, the President of the United States—Lee H. Hamilton has brought shame to halls of one of our nation’s most cherished and tax-payer supported institutions by violating its charter in favor of personal and self-serving ambitions.

Perhaps Mr. Hamilton should consider leaving his post at the WWC first, then figure out the best way to help his friend.

Donald Wilson Bush is a pragmatic conservative writer, public speaker, and global advocate for democratic causes. He is a Woodrow Wilson descendant and a student of the works of the 28th U.S. President. Mr. Bush can be reached for comment at [email protected]
Related Topic

Desecrating President Woodrow Wilson's Legacy  by David Boyadjian

For ANCA sponsored Action Alert click here.

Your rating: None Average: 4.9 (7 votes)


Armenians and the media must do a better job re WWC issue

Now that the news about the WWC and Davutoglu is being covered by the national and international media, we need more and better coverage.

Most writers are covering this issue from a mainly Jewish standpoint without mentioning the full scope of the WWC's sins.
However, Cong. Ackerman's letter is helping quite a bit.
I believe more bloggers and people are needed who can personally contact media and writers.
Send the media this:
It is national and international news that the taxpayer-funded Woodrow Wilson Center (WWC) in DC is giving the Turkish foreign minister, Ahmet Davutoglu, its top award.
The WWC is knee-deep in dirty corporate money and politics.

Cong. Gary Ackerman has severely criticized the Wilson Center. To read his letter click here.

Pres. Wilson's descendant has also weighed in against the Wilson Center. Click Pawn for the Wrong President
Background and investigative piece revealing the Wilson Center's lack of principle and its ties to dirty money. See Countercurrents.org

AGAIN, Israeli lobby provokes anger

Finally, the mainstream media and blogging world has begun covering (in the 11th hour when it was too late to stop it) the Wilson Center's award to Davutoglu. And what does the press do? The story is presented through an Israeli-filtered lens. ANY mention of Armenians (can you find them?) seems incidental. Why the hell do Armenian organizations continue to collaborate with the Israeli lobby (AND dole out awards to them)? Let's not get into how Israel's overdue recognition of the Armenian Genocide could happen to punish Turkey, not to stand the moral high ground.






Gary L. Ackerman's letter to Lee Hamilton

The Honorable Lee Hamilton
President and Director
Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars
Ronald Reagan Building and International Trade Center
One Woodrow Wilson Plaza
1300 Pennsylvania Ave NW
Washington, DC 20004-3027

Dear Lee:

I write to express my deep concern and dismay regarding the intention of the Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars (WWC) to honor Turkish Foreign Minister Ahmet Davutoglu with the WWC Public Service Award. I am keenly aware of the need for greater cooperation and understanding in the world arena, and I applaud the invaluable work the WWC has done to build ties between America and intellectual and political leaders from around the world.

These efforts truly celebrate the life and work of President Wilson, and the United States benefits greatly from the WWC’s success in promoting effective international dialogue about vital issues and building essential strategic relationships. The Congress has wisely supported the WWC, contributing about a third of its annual revenue, and I am committed to sustaining that effort.

I am, however, very strongly of the view that publicly honoring Foreign Minister Davutoglu at this time is absolutely inconsistent—absolutely inconsistent—with the mission of the WWC and the ideals that animated President Wilson’s administration and foreign policy. The actions and statements of Foreign Minister Davutoglu stand in sharp contrast to the legacy of President Wilson.

Turkey’s foreign policy under Foreign Minister Davutoglu’s leadership is rife with illegality, irresponsibility and hypocrisy. Turkey continues to not only deny the Armenian Genocide, but also to criminalize recognition of it in Turkey. Worse, Ankara threatens to break relations with states that acknowledge the role of the Ottoman Empire in the deliberate annihilation of 1.5 million Armenians as a matter of state policy. Turkey continues to militarily occupy Cyprus and to work against U.S.-backed efforts by the United Nations to resolve the conflict on that island. Turkey maintains a closed border with Armenia and has made improved relations with Armenia a political hostage to the conflict in Nagorno-Karabagh and denial of the Armenian Genocide.

Turkey recently voted against sanctions on Iran by the UN Security Council despite clear evidence that Iran’s nuclear program has violated numerous UN Security Council resolutions, and both Iran’s nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty and International Atomic Energy Agency safeguards agreement obligations. Turkey has politically backed both the genocidal regime in Sudan and the genocide-denying regime in Iran.

Turkey has fanned the flames of instability in the Middle East by rejecting Israeli efforts to channel humanitarian aid to Gaza through Israeli ports in order to ensure weapons were not going to be shipped to Hamas. Rather focusing its efforts on helping the people in Gaza, Turkey has focused on demonizing the State of Israel.

Foreign Minister Davutoglu personally described the recent flotilla incident as Turkey’s 9/11, a sickening comparison of the unfortunate deaths of nine radical anti-Israel activists who died while assaulting Israeli commandos performing a legal blockade enforcement mission, to the worst terrorist attack in history, which claimed 2,976 innocent lives in my hometown, New York City. And, despite Turkey’s own bitter history fighting against Kurdish terrorism, which has led to Turkish military operations well inside of Iraq, the Turkish government insists that Hamas, a State Department designated terrorist organization known for indiscriminate rocket fire on Israeli cities and suicide bombings in Israeli restaurants, is not a terrorist organization at all.

A foreign leader who represents and defends this kind of foreign policy, one who has championed Turkey’s most odious efforts to deny to others the human dignity that Turkey rightly expects for its own people, is not a worthy recipient of the WWC Public Service Award.

In the interest of preserving the Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars mission, namely, “advancing the ideals and concerns of Woodrow Wilson” I strongly urge you to rescind the decision to present Foreign Minister Davutoglu with the WWC Public Service Award.

Gary L. Ackerman
Subcommittee on the Middle East and South Asia


Though not spelling it out, Donald W. Bush questions not only the motives of Mr. Hamilton’s act, but also its decency – and rightly so.

Mr. Davutoglu publicly denies what Woodrow Wilson has explicitly said. In other words he calls President Wilson a liar, and is awarded the Wilson Prize.

At the very least Mr. Hamilton should be decent enough to do as suggested in the last paragraph.

Post new comment


Keghart.com edits comments for grammatical and spelling errors, obscenity, libelous, offensive and confrontational expressions. Please limit comments to a maximum of 200 words. Incomprehensible or irrelevant sentences and duplicate comments will be removed. Following receipt of your comment, Keghart.com will send you a verification email to safeguard against spam and impersonation, please click on the link in that email.
Comments are usually posted within 24 hours following your verification.

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.